★★★★½
David Lowery’s Mother Mary transforms the ghost story into something deeply intimate and emotionally corrosive. Rather than relying on traditional supernatural mechanics, Lowery crafts a film haunted by memory, fractured friendship, and the quiet devastation of abandonment. The result is a work that feels spiritually adjacent to A Ghost Story and Personal Shopper, yet ultimately more emotionally direct than either.
“A ghost story haunted less by spirits than by emotional ruin.”
From script to screen, the film moves with the confidence of singular authorship. Lowery, serving as both writer and director, constructs every aspect of the film around a precise emotional vision. Nothing feels accidental. Every visual flourish, tonal shift, and fragment of dialogue feeds into the film’s larger meditation on grief, identity, and the emotional damage left behind when relationships fracture beyond repair.
Where many modern “elevated horror” films lean heavily into ambiguity for ambiguity’s sake, Mother Mary remains emotionally grounded even when its supernatural framework becomes abstract. The film is less interested in ghosts as literal entities than in the lingering psychological weight people leave behind. It explores the horror of emotional abandonment — the slow realization that losing someone can also mean losing the version of yourself that existed alongside them.
Lowery’s dialogue plays a crucial role in establishing that atmosphere. Characters frequently speak in metaphors, but unlike many contemporary art-horror scripts, the writing never feels self-consciously poetic. The metaphors are extensions of emotional truth rather than decorative obscurity. Even when the film drifts into surreal territory, the emotional intent remains clear.
“Lowery turns memory itself into something supernatural.”
That emotional fragmentation is reinforced visually through the cinematography of Andrew Droz Palermo and Rina Yang. Their work creates two distinct visual states that constantly clash against one another. The concert sequences are glossy, dreamlike, and almost mythic in presentation, emphasizing celebrity and illusion. In contrast, the quieter present-day scenes adopt a dimmer, more grounded aesthetic that strips away glamour in favor of emotional vulnerability.
The contrast between those visual modes becomes essential to understanding the film’s unreliable emotional perspective. Certain distorted compositions and fragmented visual choices subtly suggest that what we are seeing may not be reality at all, but rather memory reshaped by grief and guilt. Lowery wisely avoids overexplaining these ideas. Instead, he allows image and atmosphere to communicate what exposition would only weaken.
The editing, also handled by Lowery, further deepens the film’s emotional rhythm. The concert scenes cut sharply and rapidly, creating a sensation of momentum and spectacle that feels almost endless. Meanwhile, the intimate dramatic sequences slow dramatically, lingering just long enough for discomfort and sadness to settle into the frame. Those pauses become crucial. The film understands when silence is more devastating than dialogue.
Yet for all of the film’s technical accomplishments, Mother Mary ultimately belongs to its performances — particularly Anne Hathaway and Michaela Coel.
Hathaway delivers some of the strongest work of her career here. Lowery gives her a role built on emotional contrast, allowing her to shift between public spectacle and private collapse with startling precision. The performance never asks for sympathy outright, yet Hathaway slowly reveals the vulnerability beneath the character’s carefully constructed image.
The film’s structure reinforces that emotional duality by constantly forcing those two versions of the character to collide against one another. Moments of glamor are immediately followed by scenes of emotional devastation, stripping away illusion almost as quickly as the film creates it.
One scene in particular — in which Coel’s character describes a vision of a dress to Hathaway’s — demonstrates exactly why the performances work so well. The sequence relies almost entirely on facial expression and emotional reaction rather than overt dramatics, yet it becomes one of the film’s most emotionally revealing moments.
“Michaela Coel doesn’t steal scenes — she quietly devastates them.”
Coel, however, may ultimately leave the larger impression. While her role operates with less overt dramatic range, she grounds the film emotionally in a way that makes its surrealism believable. Her restraint becomes the performance’s greatest strength. Small expressions, pauses, and reactions communicate entire emotional histories without requiring explanation.
Some viewers expecting a traditional supernatural narrative may find Mother Mary frustratingly restrained. The film rarely prioritizes overt horror mechanics, and its ghost story elements remain intentionally elusive. But that restraint is precisely what gives the film its power. Lowery is not interested in jump scares or mythology. He is interested in emotional residue — the way memory can distort reality until the past becomes impossible to separate from the present.
By the film’s conclusion, Mother Mary emerges as less of a ghost story than a meditation on emotional disintegration itself. Combined with its stunning costume design, haunting visual language, layered editing, and deeply controlled performances, the film becomes one of Lowery’s most emotionally mature works to date.
Rather than haunting its audience through fear, Mother Mary lingers through emotional recognition.
Related Reviews
Between Worlds: Grief, Labor, and the Unseen inPersonal Shopper
Marama (Filmfest DC 2026) Review: Gothic Restraint, Control Over Chaos
Brand New Landscape (2026) — A Quiet Devastation of Modern Fatherhood | New Directors/New Films 2026