Marly Hernández-Cortés and Stephen Schuyler’s Stealing Cars arrives with a clear intention: to capture a specific environment with an unfiltered sense of authenticity. Framed as a semi-autobiographical reflection of Baltimore life, the film positions itself less as constructed narrative than as lived experience translated to screen. In its strongest moments, that intention is visible—there is a tactile, observational quality to the world that feels drawn from memory rather than invention.
“Authenticity, here, becomes both the film’s defining strength—and its central limitation.”
There is a familiarity to the textures of the film’s setting, particularly for those with proximity to Baltimore or similar environments. The rhythms of daily life, the spaces, the social dynamics—they register as recognizable, even specific. The film succeeds in presenting a version of reality that feels grounded and unembellished, resisting the artificial polish that often defines coming-of-age narratives built around similar subject matter.
But authenticity, on its own, is not narrative—and Stealing Cars ultimately struggles to reconcile the difference.
The script lacks structural cohesion, drifting between moments without establishing a clear throughline. Scenes are presented as fragments—observations, interactions, passing encounters—but they rarely accumulate into something that feels purposeful. Instead of progression, the film offers repetition; instead of escalation, it settles into stasis. The result is a work that feels less like a story unfolding and more like a series of loosely connected impressions.
Matias, the film’s central figure, is emblematic of this approach. He is grounded, believable, and tonally consistent with the world around him, but he is never meaningfully developed beyond that foundation. The film gestures toward interiority—suggesting emotional weight, personal conflict, and the possibility of transformation—but it never commits to exploring those elements in a sustained or coherent way.
“Moments that suggest depth are introduced, then abandoned before they can take hold.”
This is particularly evident in the film’s handling of its most compelling narrative thread: the fleeting connection between Matias and a girl he encounters selling water on the street. The dynamic carries the potential to anchor the film, offering both emotional contrast and a pathway toward character development. In these moments, Stealing Cars briefly hints at a more focused and resonant film—one in which connection, however tentative, could serve as a catalyst for change.
Instead, the relationship remains underdeveloped, treated more as atmosphere than narrative. It appears, resonates briefly, and then dissipates without consequence. What could have been the film’s emotional core becomes just another fragment in a structure already defined by its lack of cohesion.
This fragmentation extends into the film’s pacing. Hernández-Cortés and Schuyler frequently linger on material that feels incidental, allowing scenes to stretch beyond their narrative utility while more substantial elements remain unexplored. The imbalance creates a rhythm that is uneven at best and disengaging at worst, reinforcing the sense that the film is more concerned with capturing moments than shaping them.
“Without structure, authenticity becomes observation—not storytelling.”
There are, however, elements that demonstrate a stronger sense of control. Chris Kennedy’s score provides a consistent tonal framework, grounding the film even when the narrative falters. It is one of the few components that feels deliberately constructed, enhancing mood and guiding the viewer through sequences that might otherwise drift. Similarly, the inclusion of music from Baltimore artist Might Mike adds a layer of cultural specificity, particularly in the film’s party scenes, where the environment feels most fully realized.
These technical strengths, while notable, cannot fully compensate for the film’s broader shortcomings. Stealing Cars achieves a degree of authenticity that is difficult to manufacture, but it fails to translate that authenticity into a compelling cinematic experience. What remains is a film caught between intention and execution—one that understands the importance of representing reality, but not how to shape it into something dramatically meaningful.
In the end, Stealing Cars is less a fully realized narrative than a collection of impressions drawn from lived experience. There is value in that, but without the structure to support it, those impressions never coalesce into something lasting.
Related Reviews
Maryland Film Festival 2026: Ugly Cry Review – A Self-Authored Debut Worth Discovering
Bouchra (Maryland Film Festival 2026): A Visually Striking Debut Undone by Narrative Drift